
Guideline 21 targets the start of the data lifecycle: collect information electronically and in structured form, through e-filing and online forms, so that quality and timeliness are built in rather than repaired later.
Most open data problems trace back to how information was first captured. A form filled on paper and retyped later will always be slower and messier than one submitted online into a structured field.
What the guideline means
Publishing good data is far easier when the data was collected well. Guideline 21 asks governments to modernize collection, particularly through electronic filing, so records are created in structured form at the moment information is submitted. E-filing cuts transcription errors, saves money, and makes near-real-time publication possible (see Guideline 22).
The guideline also flags details that are easy to overlook: a policy should define what a complete electronic filing is, and what happens if the filing system goes down. Paper should remain an option only where filers cannot reasonably be expected to have access to the technology.
Model policy language patterns
Paraphrased examples of collection provisions:
- The most frequently used forms and documents shall be made available for completion and submission online.
- The oversight body shall establish processes that improve how data is collected as well as how it is published.
- Technical standards shall govern how departments capture and structure data intended for publication.
- Data creation processes shall be designed with eventual public release in mind (compare Guideline 14).
Where it appears in adopted policies
Collection provisions appear in a modest number of policies in this index:
- Memphis, TN (2009), one of the earliest local orders, called for the most commonly used forms to be completed and submitted online.
- Fort Collins, CO (2017) explicitly listed optimizing methods of data collection among its implementation tasks.
- Asheville, NC (2015) directed its IT department to publish technical standards for public datasets.
- Las Vegas, NV (2016) and New Orleans, LA (2016) tied collection to inventory and release processes.
Common pitfalls
- Digitizing the paper form, not the data. A fillable PDF that is printed and scanned is not e-filing.
- Free text everywhere. Collecting addresses, categories or amounts as unstructured text makes later analysis painful.
- No outage plan. Without a rule for system downtime, filers and agencies dispute deadlines.
- Parallel streams. Collecting one version for internal use and another for publication invites inconsistency (see Guideline 28).
A practical checklist for collection provisions
- Identify the highest-volume paper forms and move them online first.
- Capture categories, dates, amounts and locations in structured fields rather than free text.
- Define what counts as a complete electronic submission.
- Set a rule for deadlines when the filing system is unavailable.
- Keep a non-electronic path for filers who lack reasonable access to technology.
- Design new systems so the data they collect can be published without manual re-entry, linking collection to the inventory and release process.
Why this matters for your business data
The same principle determines whether a company's operational data is worth anything to an outside buyer. Businesses that capture work through structured systems, such as dispatch tools, job-costing software, inventory or booking platforms, generate records that can be analyzed and, once de-identified, licensed. Businesses that run on paper tickets and spreadsheets typed after the fact usually hold less usable data, even if they hold more of it.
If you are deciding whether your records are structured enough to be valuable, the valuation calculator gives a quick estimate and how to value my data explains which collection habits raise or lower price. The open data policy to data value guide shows the parallel in more depth.
We never take HIPAA/PHI data or personal customer data. Everything is de-identified before it leaves your control.
Frequently asked questions
What is e-filing in an open data context?
E-filing means requiring or enabling people and businesses to submit information to government electronically, through structured online forms rather than paper. Campaign finance reports, permits and licensing applications are common examples. The structured submission becomes the data that can later be published.
Should e-filing be mandatory?
The guideline suggests requiring electronic filing where filers can reasonably be expected to have access to the necessary technology, while keeping alternatives for those who cannot. It also recommends defining what counts as a complete filing and how system outages are handled.
How does data collection affect data quality?
Most quality problems originate at capture: inconsistent categories, retyped values and missing fields. Collecting data in structured form at the source prevents many errors that would otherwise require cleanup before publication, and it makes faster publication possible.
Policies in the index that reflect guideline 21
| Place | Adopted | Instrument | Guidelines |
|---|---|---|---|
| Memphis, TN | Oct 10, 2009 | Executive order (No. 01-2009) | 23212627 |
| Asheville, NC | Oct 13, 2015 | Council resolution | 13489101118 |
| Las Vegas, NV | Apr 12, 2016 | Administrative policy (City Manager policy CM510) | 12345678 |
| New Orleans, LA | Sep 1, 2016 | Executive order (MJL 16-01) | 124511182124 |
| Fort Collins, CO | Feb 7, 2017 | Council resolution | 12345678 |
Sources
Updated December 31, 2024.